HomePhotography IndexPage 1Page 2Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6
1

.

.

Canon EOS 5D Review

New Millennium Classic

Peter Kun Frary


.....

Canon's consumer DSLR legacy began with the ground-breaking 3 megapixel (MP) EOS D30 in 2001. Five years hence Canon unleashed another coup de théâtre, the full frame 12.8 MP EOS 5D. Yes, full frame megabuck Canon and Kodak DSLRs existed for years prior to 2005. What makes the 5D unique is price point--$3000--the same as the APS-C EOS D30 in 2001. Plus, it's petite compared to an EOS 1D series body. Although many pros bought the 5D, it was the ultimate doctor-lawyer-yuppie puppy camera. And judging from the amount of silly 5D questions on photo forums in 2006, it quickly ascended to boy-toy status.

Waianae God Beams EOS 5D & EF 70-200 4L USM

Major Features

The form factor and most features were morphed from the EOS 20D. So nothing ground-breaking here. Think of the EOS 5D as a 20D on steroids with no cropping factor and popup flash. If you grew up with an EOS 35mm SLR in your sweaty mitts, you'll feel at home with the 5D. It looks, feels, operates and smells like an EOS. Moving from a 10D, I found it easy to configure and operate. I barely needed to crack the manual.

Canon EOS 5D • Looks, feels, operates and smells like an EOS.

Nine-Point Wide Area Auto Focus borrowed from the EOS 20D plus 6 "invisible" AF sensors that kick in during AI servo tracking. It retains the cool flashing AF rectangles but lacks eye-controlled focus (ECF). The omission of ECF is a major failing for Canon and makes AF selection slower and less convenient than the lowly $350 Elan 7NE.

Quiet Operation. It ain't no Elan 7 but mirror slap is softer than the 20D and 30D but louder than the 10D and Elan 7. With a USM lens, this is a quiet camera.

Burst Mode. Continuous frame rate clocks at 3 FPS for a total of 60 large JPEGS or 17 RAW frames before the RAM buffer chokes. Maybe not fast enough for sports pros but fast enough for doctors, lawyers, professors and yuppie puppies.

Shutter Speeds. 1/8000 to 30 seconds in 1/3 or 1/2 stop increments. Bulb and self timer ability. 1/200 flash sync. Studio flash works best at 1/125 or 1/60 second.

Three Metering Patters: 35-zone evaluative, center weighted, 8% partial and 3.5% spot. Unlike the Elan 7 and other earlier EOS, partial and spot metering can't be linked to the active AF sensor.

ISO 50 to 3200 are available at the touch of a button and spin of a dial. Digital noise, like film grain, increases with ISO speed. However 5D noise control is so good I wouldn't hesitate to use any ISO setting from 50-1600 if warranted. A big improvement over the EOS 10D and it wasn't bad.

Exposure Modes: gone are the programmed "PIC" modes (sports, night, portrait, etc.). However full auto, programmed AE, aperture priority, shutter priority and manual remain. Oddly depth of field mode (DEP) is MIA. Of course, you can override P, Av and TV modes with -2 to +2 of exposure compensation or auto bracketing.

White Balance control including Auto, Preset, Custom, Color Temperature, Correction and Bracketing.

Tall Ship at Aloha Tower • EOS 5D and EF 50 1.4 USM • Reflections of a ship at sunset

Picture Style settings for simple image color and contrast control. There are 6 preset styles: Standard, Portrait, Landscape, Neutral, Faithful and Monochrome plus 3 User Defined settings. If you shoot RAW, you may change styles during conversion in Digital Photo Professional.

E-TTL II Flash. The popup flash is MIA so you'll need an EX series Speedlite. An EX series flash such as the 430EX offers cool ETTL features such as High-Speed Sync (FP), wireless multiple Speedlites with ratio control, Flash Exposure Lock (FE), AE flash compensation and 2nd curtain sync. If you have a Speedlite without onboard controls, e.g., 420EX or 220EX, you can access most E-TTL features with camera controls.

Dioptric Adjustment (-3.0 to + 1.0) is built into the eyepiece. You won't care about this if you have 20/20 vision, but a sharp viewfinder for the rest of us makes for better shooting.

21 Custom Functions let you customize controls and/or features in 57 different combinations. For example, you may move AF activation to the AE/FE Lock button or disable auto fill-in flash reduction.

Depth of Field Preview is available via a small button on the front of the camera. This button also doubles as a modeling light when used with the an EX series flash in wireless mode.

Mirror Lockup is enabled by setting a custom function. Locking up the mirror helps avoid vibration during high magnification photography or slow shutter speeds. It's a royal pain in the arse to set a CF when you need this feature, not to mention remembering to disable it afterwards. Too bad it can't be linked to the self timer like it's film ancestor, the EOS 5.

12.8 Megapixel CMOS Sensor. The 5D produces 4368 x 2912 pixel images (smaller sizes available). Raw, JPEG and simultaneous Raw with JPEG file formats are available. Unlike earlier Canon DSLRs, the Raw with JPEG format no longer embeds the JPEG in the RAW file. So, extraction with special software no longer needed. You can drag 'n drop the RAW and JPEGs straight from the CF card. This feature is welcome for RAW shooters wishing to leave JPEGS on a friend's computer lacking Canon software.

2.5 Inch LCD. TFT color LCD with 230,000 pixels, 5 levels of brightness and 170 degree viewing angle. A bit dim but otherwise great.

Magnesium Body. The metal body shell gives the EOS 5D heft and a solid but comfy feel. In the hand, it feels like an EOS 1V. The contoured grip fits my hand nicely. The Battery Grip BG-ED4 is also magnesium and adds to the tactile elegance of the body.

Computer Interface. The direct USB 2 connection to a computer is painfully S-L -O -W. Feels like USB 1.1 on a bad day. Too bad it doesn't have Firewire. Surely it wouldn't have cost much more. You'll want to use a Firewire or USB 2 compact flash card reader to upload images to your computer.

Summer of '69 • Las Vegas • EOS 5D, EF 24-105 4L IS USM • A celebration of Hippie Culture on Fremont Street.

Included Accessories

ImageBrowser, PhotoStitch, EOS Capture and Digital Photo Professional (DPP) are included in the software package. Canon's download and raw conversion software works well, but is a bit slow and chunky. However, they are extremely stable under Mac OS 10.39 and 10.4x. I like DPP but the drawing of thumbnails and view enlargement is slow compared to ImageBrowser or PhotoShop. You'll want to invest in a file management program like Aperture or Adobe Light Table.

A single-well battery charger, BP-511A lithium ion battery, neck strap with Canon Digital emblazoned across it, manual, USB cable and video cable are included too. A compact flash card is not included. Thus, you'll need to purchase a mitt full of 4GB or larger compact flash cards and, of course, a Firewire or USB 2 CF card reader as well.

©Copyright 2006-2012 by Peter Kun Frary • All Rights Reserved

.

 
HomePhotography IndexPage 1Page 2Page 3Page 4Page 5Page 6
1