.
HomePhotography Index Previous PagePage 1Page 2Page 3Page 4 • Page 5
5

.

.

Canon EOS 10D • Accessories & Conclusion

Peter Kun Frary

Essential Accessories

The EOS 10D may use any of the 50 plus Canon EF lenses (but not EF-s) and most other EOS system accessories. If you're tempted by a used third party lens, try it before you buy. Most older Sigma and Tokina lenses will not work without a new ROM chip.

Sand Island Cranes • EOS 10D & EF 70-200 4L USM

Lenses

The typical "normal" zoom of the film era, 28-70 or 28-105, isn't wide enough for scenics and groups shots due to the EOS 10D's 1.6x cropping factor. However the EF 24-85 3.5-4.5 USM is an excellent general purpose starter zoom. This lens is approximately equivalent to a 35-135 zoom in the 35 mm format, an wonderful range for scenics, travel and portraits. It's worth paying a little more for better optics, distance scale, silent AF motor, faster AF (internal focus), metal mount, manual focus override and faster aperture. If you're a wide angle buff, you probably won't even consider an EOS 10D. However, the EF 17-40 4L USM (28-65 equivalent 35 mm coverage) is kickin' if you desire a moderately wide zoom, bulletproof construction, have bucks to burn and don't mind a little bulk. Be forewarned the EF 17-40 4L USM blocks the popup flash on the wide end so don't buy one unless you own a Speedlite.

Canon EF 24-85 3.5-4.5 USMAn ideal walk around lens for the EOS 10D (black available)

The EF 24-85 3.5-4.5 USM and EF 70-200 4L USM complement one another well and make an excellent kit if you need additional reach.

Battery Grip BG-ED3

I shoot lots of verticals and can't imagine using the EOS 10D without the Battery Grip BG-ED3, affectionately known as "Big Ed." The vertical shutter release, AE/FE lock, main input dial and focusing point selector make shooting verticals as easy as horizontals. It also sports a tripod socket and set of lugs for a handstrap or neckstrap. The additional grip surface improves handling and balance with larger lenses and flash units.

The EOS 10D/BG-ED3 combo isn't as comfortable as the EOS 3/PB-E2 combo. However it does fit relatively snugly. Like the Elan 7E/BP-300, I can feel a small amount of play when I grab Big Ed for verticals with telephotos. If you go on long shoots, you'll appreciate the ability to use two BP-511 batteries. Unfortunately, the Battery Grip BG-ED3 is plastic and lacks the tactile elegance of the magnesium 10D. With that said, it feels better made than the BG-E2 for the EOS 20D/30D.

Big Ed (Battery Grip BG-ED3) • Big Ed makes shooting verticals easy.

 

BP-511 Li-ion Battery Pack

Canon is overly optimistic about battery life, estimating 650 images on a single charge! Shooting RAW with a small embedded JPEG (ISO 100), a new Canon BP-511 yields 75-100 images with 2 second review and no popup flash. A SterlingTrek 511 yields about 500 images. Needless to say, you'll want another BP-511 battery for travel or long shoots. A completely exhausted battery takes about 90 minutes to recharge. Postscript (12/2005): Canon BP-511 batteries are only good for one to two years of moderate use. Expect to buy spares every year.

Remote Switch RS-80N3

An electronic cable release is available, the RS-80N3, for exposures requiring vibration control. Fortunately, it's more beefy than the wimpy remote switch for the Elan and Rebel series (RS60-E3). The RS-80N3 behaves exactly like the shutter button: half depress locks AF and exposure and full depress fires the shutter. You may trip the shutter from 2.6 feet away. The RS-80N3 is also used for the EOS 3, 1V, 1D and 1Ds.

The remote port is on the left side of the camera under a rubber boot. You simply peel the boot upwards to reveal USB, video and remote ports. The cover is attached to the camera with a rubber hinge, so there's no chance of losing it. This design is more convenient than the tiny plastic caps on the EOS 1V and 3. The RS-80N3 snaps in the port quickly and easily, but fits only one way. Unlike earlier EOS designs, the RS-80N3 is easy to connect in the dark. Of course, you should practice connecting it during daylight before venturing into the field.

 

Final Remarks

As a chrome shooter that prefers late afternoon landscapes I have a few pertinent observations. First, the CMOS sensor is similar to slide film in terms of exposure latitude and photographic range. Specifically, the CMOS sensor can record images with about a 5 stop range from shadows to highlights. Thus, contrasty scenes--e.g., landscape with setting sun--are beyond the ability of the sensor to fully record. If you're used to the extreme latitude of negative film, you'll have to refine your metering technique. Something has to go, either shadow detail or highlights, and herein lies the dilemma.

To make matters worse, highlights are easier to blow out than slide film! Thus, you'll need to place important highlights at one extreme of the photographic range (far right of histogram) and let the mids and shadows fall where they may. The good news is shadow detail is fairly easy to recover with a little fancy dancing during RAW conversion and Photoshop tweaks. Nevertheless, the 10D is at its best in the soft, even lighting of overcast days, open shade or in controlled studio lighting.

Tillamook Bay • EOS 10D & EF 24-85 3.5-4.5 USM

Best Features

One of the coolest features of the EOS 10D is adjustable ISO. Low light shooting and hand held telephotos shots are just a menu away. ISO 100-400 is very clean and smooth in appearance. Higher settings are useable but rather gritty by ISO 800. I wouldn't use ISO 1600 except in an emergency. ISO 3200 is pointillistic! However, 15 to 30 second exposures at ISO 100 have amazingly little noise (Fireworks).

Another big plus is the 10D behaves and operates like an Elan 7E or A2, but, unlike those models, is built like a tank. Most camera controls are so familiar I hardly needed to crack the manual. Plus, all my lenses, remotes and flash units work on the 10D.

Although the imaging sensor has the familiar 2:3 aspect ratio, it is smaller than an APS frame, and thus yields a 1.6x cropping factor. In other words, lenses have an apparent magnification of 1.6x. This cropping factor is bad for wide angle buffs but great for telephoto freaks.

A small sensor has the benefit of using the sharpest part of the image circle--the center. Thus, consumer zoom lenses are stellar performers. This performance boost isn't limited to sharpness or virtual elimination of vignetting and light fall off. After shooting several sunsets with my 10D, EF 24-85 3.5-4.5 USM and EF 70-200 4L USM I came to a startling revelation: the 10D somehow increases flare resistance. Both these zooms exhibit some ghosting and flare when shooting sunsets with full frame 35 mm gear. That is, one or more mirror images or blobs of the sun are visible in the frame. Perhaps increased flare resistance is due to the cropping factor or the way light strikes the sensor, I'm not sure. All I know are all my zooms are now fit for eye fryin' Hawaiian sunsets! Check out these sunset images 1234

Finally, 8 x 12 enlargements printed on a Fuji Digital Frontier minlab are breathtaking: sharp, grainless and vivid. Incidently, little or no unsharpmask is needed for 8 x 12 prints--they look photographically sharp as is (low rez images for web display need unsharpmask). Nevertheless, if you're accustomed to the over processed images of a point 'n shooter , you may not be happy with the 10D or any DSLR for that matter.

Sunlight in Trees • Roundtop Drive • EOS 10D & EF 17-40 4L USM

Dissapointments

The biggest letdowns are narrow exposure latitude and the tendency to overexpose highlights in contrasty scenes. In bright sun, I typically set -1/3 or -1/2 stop exposure compensation to keep highlights from blowing out. In dimmer and/or more even light, exposure is usually fine.

I'm extremely disappointed Eye Controlled Focus (ECF) was omitted from the 10D. I use ECF much of the time on my Elan 7E and EOS 3. Automatically selected AF sensors aren't reliable, i.e., the camera often focuses on the wrong subject. Selecting AF sensors manually is too slow and chunky for fast changing situations. Unfortunately, the dedicated AF selector buttons of the Elan 7 are missing too! So, I use the center AF sensor and/or FEL and perform the lock AF-recompose-dance. Reminds me of using my old 1989 EOS 630!

Why doesn't the 10D work with the Remote Controller RC-1, an inexpensive wireless remote? The Elan series and the new Digital Rebel (EOS 300D) can use it! Instead, 10D shooters must spring for the expensive and bulky Wireless Controller LC-4.

The viewfinder is reasonably bright and contrasty, but small and slightly dim compared to my EOS 3, A2 or Elan 7E. Even a Rebel Ti has a huge viewfinder in comparison! The small viewfinder makes it difficult to compose precisely and caused a marked increase in slopped horizons in my images.

Conclusion

The EOS 10D's refined ergonomics, beefy construction and photographic flexibility make it easy to produce beautiful images. Although it has a few zits, the EOS 10D boasts the best value to performance ratio in of any DSLR in 2003. If you're an experienced EOS shooter (film or digital), you'll find an easy learning curve. However, a point 'n shooter will need months of study and practice to master the 10D's wealth of features.

Highly recommended for serious amateurs, tweakers and pros that find an EOS 1D series overkill. Not recommended for wide angle lovers, point 'n shooters and those wishing to travel light.

Postscript (6/2007)

It's been 4 years since I wrote this review and the 10D has proved to be both durable and dependable. Incidentally, the CMOS sensor still doesn't need cleaning (no dust bunnies at F22!). The 511 batteries only lasted a year but the camera still works perfectly. The SilverTrek 511 replacement batteries I bought have proved to be far more durable than the originals.

More Images taken with the EOS 10D (click to enlarge)

     
     

Source Materials

Canon EOS 10D Instruction Manual. Tokyo: Canon, 2003 (CT1-1241-000).

Firmware Updates

1.0.1 Improves reliability of USB communication during direct printing. Corrects of Chinese characters display in the menu system.

2.0.0 This firmware update adds PictBridge support and fixes 3 bugs: improves release lag when using Microdrives; corrects AE Lock operation when using custom function 4 settings; and fixes exposure compensation display errors when using the ST-E2 Speedlite Transmitter.

2.0.1 This firmware fixes the display of color temperature in playback mode after pressing the INFO button.

Canon EOS Forums

Bob Atkins Canon EOS forum

FM Canon EOS Forum

Canon EOS Equipment Resources

Canon Camera Museum

Canon Malaysia

DSLRs, Lenses and Film

EOS Documentation Project

Photo.net • Canon EOS SLRs

6/25/2003 • Updated 10/17/2011

©Copyright 2003-2012 by Peter Kun Frary • All Rights Reserved

.

.
HomePhotography Index Previous PagePage 1Page 2Page 3Page 4 • Page 5
5